P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

4.3
Very Good
492 reviews
 $
(212) 926-3155   |   Visit Website

About

P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant in New York, New York is a full-service Italian restaurant offering a wide selection of authentic Italian dishes, as well as a pizza delivery service. Customers can expect to find classic staples such as handmade pasta, fresh sauces and a wide range of delicious pizzas, each crafted to perfection in the pizza restaurant. With a warm and inviting atmosphere and a commitment to quality, P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant is the perfect destination for a classic Italian dining experience.

Ratings for P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!

  • Overall Rating
    4.3 (492)
  • google google
    4.6 (223)
  • opentable opentable
    4.2 (186)
  • yelp yelp
    4 (73)
  • foursquare foursquare
    6.1 /10
    6.1 (10)

Reviews for P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.

Michael G.

The pizza is delicious, portions are generous, and the customer service is great -- they will go above and beyond to get your order to you correct, fresh, and on time. -1 star becayse I was really disappointed with the fettuccine alfredo. It was $21 with chicken and tasted very bland, no flavor at all. Very sharp contrast with the pizza, which is great.

Paul T.

In a neighborhood filled with great, affordable food of several types, P&M Pizza still stands out. The owners are old-school guys who genuinely care about the quality of their work, and are always kind and conversational. The pizza is terrific, but my son and I both love the meatball subs, and my wife goes for the lasagna. This was the first place we ate when we moved into the neighborhood about 10 months ago, and it's now a good, comforting part of our lives. Always a treat.

Orié T.

The basic cheese pizza is the best one. One of the best pizza I ever had in NYC and MA. The crust is not too thick or too thin, just perfect and crunchy. The flavor is not too salty, not too sweet and perfect. The best part is even it get cold, the taste still great! I love those men who seem to be the owners and running the business for many decades still making great pizza and serving customers. Honestly, better than infamous Artichoke pizza of NYC or the best recommended pizza places on the tourist guide.

Photos

Business Photo

Business Hours

Sunday:
Closed
Monday:
10:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday:
10:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday:
10:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thursday:
Closed
Friday:
10:30 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday:
10:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Location Map

1747 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10031

Nearby eatery spots, restaurants and foodtrucks

Ecuatoriana Restaurant

1685 Amsterdam Ave
New York, New York

Wimpy's Restaurant

1822 Amsterdam Ave
New York, New York

Famous Fish Market

684 St Nicholas Ave
New York, New York

Mamasushi

3569 Broadway
New York, New York

Caridad Restaurant

3533 Broadway
New York, New York