O'Toole's Libertyville

We recently went to O’Toole’s for drinks and appetizers. We had a good time at this place. The waitress was nice and also very patient with us. Someone in our group broke two glasses during our time and the waitress quickly cleaned up the mess and brought new drinks. I would definitely come back.

My second time dining at O'tooles. Definitely a popular spot and gets quite busy. Parking at the street and in back area is quite easy. There is an outdoor patio, bar area, main dining and private dining area so lots of options. Last time we got the burgers and they were quite tasty and are large portions. This time we got two items from the special menu. The Mahi Mahi with the pineapple dressing and pumpkin seeds was so delicious. Fish was cooked perfectly to be moist and tender, the sauce paired with it very well. The Birria fries was underwhelming and a bit dry, would not recommend. Our friends got the Korean sandwich and a burrito bowl and they both enjoyed. So I'd say generally food tends to be on the good side. Lots of beer options and cocktails. I know they have different specials daily for drinks and food. They also have trivia on Tuesdays which is something fun to try and join.

Super friendly staff, cozy covered patio, and interesting stuff on the menu = nice spot for a late lunch! I ordered the salmon burger, and appreciated that the side of tots was NOT huge... the "burger" patty was a bit odd, though, like it was made with canned salmon & breadcrumbs when I'd been expect something a bit more fresh and juicy. Next time, will try something else.