Nicola Restaurant & Bar

4.5
Wonderful
2333 reviews
 $$
(614) 459-7000   |   Visit Website

About

Nicola Restaurant & Bar in Columbus, Ohio offers a beautiful and elegant atmosphere to enjoy a casual Italian meal. The relaxed ambience of the bar welcomes guests with an extensive menu and wide selection of drinks. The restaurant provides a pleasant setting for a romantic evening out or a night out with friends. Nicola's Italian cuisine is sure to satisfy any discerning food lover.

Restaurant Features

Facilities & Amenities

  • Restroom Restroom
  • Bar Bar
  • Wifi Available
  • Kid Friendly Kid Friendly
  • Kid Menu Kid Menu
  • Kid High Chair Kid High Chair
  • Vegetarian Options Veg Friendly
  • Alcohol Alcohol
  • Happy Hour Specials Happy Hour
  • Wheelchair Accessible Wheelchair Access

Accepted Payments

  • Credit Card
  • Apple Pay
  • Google Pay

Ratings for Nicola Restaurant & Bar

Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!

  • Overall Rating
    4.5 (2333)
  • google google
    4.4 (440)
  • opentable opentable
    4.7 (1458)
  • yelp yelp
    4 (162)
  • facebook facebook
    4.2 (161)
  • zomato zomato
    4 (78)
  • foursquare foursquare
    7.2 /10
    7.2 (34)

Reviews for Nicola Restaurant & Bar

We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.

Kevin K.

A group of four. A beautiful night which helped the overall experience. Service was good and thankfully not over eager. Food was so, so for 3 of us. The spaghetti dish with calamari and “claims” (misspelled on the menu) was awful. $60/person with a 18% tip. Had plans to go back with a group of 11 the following Saturday, but determined it wasn’t worth it. By the way, I don’t do critiques very often, so don’t think this is just some grumpy old guy letting some steam out. Frankly, I’m a tad worried about the clams and thought I would save others the potential misfortune I may have yet to experience.

bruce h.

This was our anniversary and we wanted to celebrate with fine tasting Italian food. This was it! Outside on their patio, sipping a tasty, tart cocktail and a nice Barbera red. We love caprese and adding basil pesto is a keeper. The Tuscan Nido was perfect-handmade and hands down the largest ravioli-the added surprise of an egg yolk hidden inside was genius! The Filetto Di Maiale(pork tenderloin) was perfectly cooked and the flavor was mouth watering, even as I ate it! We wrapped it up with their lemon cake. Oh, man, so light and lemony. We took smaller and smaller bites so it would last longer. Give them a go, we’ll certainly be back!

Austin E.

I don't post or write reviews but let me tell you something…..I had dinner here earlier today with a party from work and I enjoyed it so much I couldn’t resist not to write a review! We had the Seafood Spaghetti with the clams and it was absolutely delicious! I have eaten all around the world and this top of the top! Cheers to the homemade limoncello we had to top of a great night! ????

Menu / Photos

Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo

Business Hours

Sunday:
Closed
Monday:
4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday:
4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday:
4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Thursday:
4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Friday:
4:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday:
4:30 PM - 10:00 PM

Location Map

4740 Reed Rd
Columbus, OH 43220

Nearby eatery spots, restaurants and foodtrucks

Noodles and Company

4740 Reed Rd
Upper Arlington, Ohio

BIBIBOP Asian Grill

1836 W Henderson Rd
Columbus, Ohio

Windward Passage

4739 Reed Rd
Columbus, Ohio

Restaurant Silla-Korean Cuisine

1802 W Henderson Rd
Columbus, Ohio

Ridiculous Eatz

1942 W Henderson Rd
Columbus, Ohio