New Baltimore Ice Cream

The best ice cream I have had in quite some time. Very flavorful. Polite and friendly staff.

They have locations on rt 44 and rt 619, which is the one I usually visit. It's a cash only business so don't expect to use your debit card there. Their ice cream is homemade and they always have 6-8 flavors that change as they run out of one and add another. The fruity and nutty flavors always have lots of chunks of the real thing. No artificial flavors that fade away after a couple of bites! The cone sizes are generous and it's funny to see first time customers order a 'large' and then say something like 'wow, that's huge! I had no idea a large was that big!' There are lots of sundae toppings too and you can choose the flavor of ice cream for your personal taste. No extra charge for whipped cream and chopped nuts on top! They have Facebook posts for each location which show the current flavors of ice cream and their business hours which change as summer moves into fall. Sadly, they are a seasonal business that closes around the end of September and doesn't open again until late spri

Awesome ice cream stand. One of the best around. Has a miniature golf course right behind also