Il Mulino New York - Miami

The service was fabulous from beginning to the end. Everyone was very attentive and professional. We liked getting fresh cut cheese and an assortment of bread while we were reading the menu. The steak was super delicious and soft. The beef carpaccio was OK but was missing flavor. The drains were a little overpriced. For dessert we got a small happy anniversary cake on the house which was very lovely and we appreciated that nice gesture a lot! Ambience was nice It’s located in a nice resort by the water, it has cute tables and a two level floor plan. The lighting could use some update so that the room is lit up everywhere with soft lights and no hard light from the top that makes shadows on faces. Grappa after the food was great too!

First of all I am not payed by anyone (like most of the "local guides" that are rating 4/5 stars this place, after a payment or a free dinner) so my review will be absolutely fair, honest and thorough. I visited Il Mulino with my family and my friend's family. Food is TERRIBLE (we were there on September 18th '22 so it is all trackable). Appetizers (fried zucchini and fried bread) soaking in a fried oil (not even dried before being served) of bad quality and smelling like something that was dipping in oil for a very long time. Main course was even worse. We had Saltimbocca. OMG! The most simple recipe in Italy literally killed by a chef. Plenty of salt, poor quality of the meat and a sort of gravy sauce mixed with burnt salvia and spinach underneath (see posted photo) without any culinary logic. My son got a kids beef fillet. Meat was of the poorest quality ever (like frozen) and french fries even worse (again dipping in the fried oil and not dried like the zucchini above). We tried so

Wonderful charming restaurant! The best service - professionalism is in everything. This place is very refined, fresh flowers on the tables, romantic atmosphere. We have been here several times. I highly recommend to try “Sunset Menu” there. You will have an unforgettable experience and will definitely find dishes to your taste. If you like seafood try the next two dishes: “Polipo Alla Griglia” - so delicious, octopus melt in mouth; “Filetto Di Branzino” - very tender and juicy.