Chef Paolino Cafe

Solid Trattoria with beer and wine as well as NYC Italian pastries and Oyster Bar on Wednesdays over the winter. Recently had their mussels in white wine and full size New York style sausage and mushroom pepperoni pizza (pics). Summer 2022 dad always gets the shrimp salad wrap this year. It was noticeably smaller than in the past. Hope that's not a trend. Suggest you order the combo pizza which allows three toppings. Cheaper than just ordering two toppings on their own. Both the muscles and the pizza were delicious. I even dipped the pizza a little bit into the broth. Another recent visit had three slices, tomato, spinach and mushrooms (pic). They were all delicious. We also love the shrimp salad wrap. Great big shrimp and tasty. My vegetarian wife loves their baked ziti and Mom and I love their seafood pastas with white, rosé, or marinara sauces. A lot of their stuff uses homemade sauce which is fantastic. And we also love their garlic knots. The garlic bread tends to be too hard but

Just got a large pepperoni pizza, Italian cold cut and cheese steak...should asked for mayo - I think that's what was missing ...the pizza was killer...hasn't changed. Cheese steak was actually really good - wife and I think there is more than enough meat on there...why offer double meat?

The best New York style pizza for at least 30 miles. Crust and cheese are perfect. The price even more perfect. The large salad is enough for two or three people. Please have the garlic knots they really are great. We tried so many other places that claimed to be new York style but all failed. The counter service style was very good