About
Carmela's Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant located in New Carlisle, Ohio. Along with serving pizza, Carmela's also acts as a bar and a buffet restaurant. Patrons have the option to dine in, take away, or even have their pizza delivered right to their door. Customers especially enjoy the restaurant's entertaining atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious food. Whether one wants to casually have dinner with family or celebrate a special occasion, Carmela's Pizzeria has something for everyone.
Ratings for Carmelas Pizzeria
Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!
- Overall Rating
google
facebook
yelp
zomato
tripadvisor
Reviews for Carmelas Pizzeria
We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.
I LOVE their Chicken Wings, which I get with bone in and unbreaded and with a mild sauce. I picked ore up Sunday before start of NFL season games. This is the BEST Sports Bar in Medway / New Carlisle area including all Clubs. Many TV's, Beer & Drinks / Great Food. Plus people were brining children in, a good Family Place. NOT a Biker Bar, which is way too common in this area. THE BEST SPORTS BAR RESTAURANT in this area. I would say like Slyders in Dayton but this is Better because more TV's. ...Now Me I would 86 the pictures on old farmers and put up more Sports stuff including Local Tecumseh School banners, but perhaps the old farmer pictures cut down on the Trouble Maker Crowd.....I would rather eat here than The Mel-O-Dee....To Me, this place is better than Moose, Eagles, VFW, AmVets, and any other bar or club to watch The Games. THE BEST Family Sports Bar Restaurant going. Most places have the Game on and Beer, but they don't have Food like this I like that they keep it
Great Pizza and Salad buffet today! Food was good and not too pricey at all! I plan to go back again this summer and have drinks and dinner on their patio! Friendly staff and excellent experience both times I've been there so far! Keep up the good work!
No one sat us - no sign saying to seat yourself. After 5 minutes standing at the front door, finally one (of the 2) servers says "OH you can seat yourself". Luckily, I thought to grab menus as no one came to our table for 8.5 minutes (yup, I timed it. I write these reviews nationally, and this was a first and now ONLY time visit). Food took 30+ minutes to come to the table, but was tasty enough. Easy to tell Mac&Cheese bites were frozen and recooked. Sadly, this location is the LAST in a dying chain that has been in the area for a while. Not hard to tell why. 1 Meatlovers 14" $21, 1 Cheese 7" $5, 1 Mac&Cheese bites $9.50 plus drinks. Total was almost $50!!! Freaking craziness. Won't be coming back, and hope this place puts itself out of its misery quickly.
Photos

Business Hours
| Sunday: | 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM |
| Monday: | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |
| Tuesday: | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |
| Wednesday: | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |
| Thursday: | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |
| Friday: | 11:00 AM - 12:00 AM |
| Saturday: | 12:00 PM - 12:00 AM |
