Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant

4.5
Wonderful
1428 reviews
 $$
(414) 963-9623   |   Visit Website

About

Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant in Milwaukee, Wisconsin is an excellent addition to the bustling culinary landscape of the area. This sicilian restaurant brings authentic Italian cuisine to the heart of Wisconsin and quickly became a treasured pizza restaurant. Dishes are cooked to perfection in the traditional Italian manner to satisfy even the most discerning of taste buds. Carini's offers an exquisite menu for all to enjoy, and remains a beloved part of the local dining scene.

Ratings for Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant

Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!

  • Overall Rating
    4.5 (1428)
  • google google
    4.5 (405)
  • opentable opentable
    4.6 (591)
  • facebook facebook
    4.5 (178)
  • yelp yelp
    4 (142)
  • tripadvisor tripadvisor
    4.5 (78)
  • zomato zomato
    3.9 (34)

Reviews for Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant

We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.

C S.

I want to give them more stars but the interaction with certain staff made me decide on only 3. The female staff that assisted during our group reservation for a birthday, were upset that we wanted all guests to be seated together, which I thought was the point of making the reservation. We were not told until we arrived that we had to request for all guests to be seated together. The staff then were upset that we asked for the tables to be moved together to accommodate us. Maybe it's me but it doesn't make sense to make a large reservation and then have to turn around to a different table just to speak to a guest in your own group. Had I known this was an issue during the time of making the reservation I would have asked for us to be placed together or just found a different restaurant to go to. The remainder of our time eating the staff who gave us initial issues stared at our table angrily from a distance as if we were wrong for not knowing how they chose to coordinate reservations(

Timothy V.

Wait staff pleasant and efficient. I had arugula salad for a starter. Tasty but cut those stems off. Friends steak was a little overcooked but flavor was excellent. No pizzas that night but they are amazing. I had a shrimp and angel hair dish. Not enough stuff but huge pile of pasta so a little bland. I took care of that with some requested olive oil and pepper flakes. I love a family restaurant and it's a pleasant spot. Go and relax and enjoy .

Sherif M.

Absolutely loved it, the chef came himself and greeted us and talked about how the restaurant is a family business and that they cook the same way they cook at their homes. Their garlic and spices olive oil is a gem!! Highly recommended!! Vegetarian options: There are many vegetarian options Parking: Easy street parking Dietary restrictions: They offer halal meat

Menu / Photos

Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo
Business Photo

Business Hours

Sunday:
3:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
Closed
Wednesday:
3:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Thursday:
Closed
Friday:
3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Saturday:
3:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Location Map

3468 N Oakland Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53211

Nearby eatery spots, restaurants and foodtrucks

Harry's Bar and Grill

3549 N Oakland Ave
Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Crave Cafe

3592 N Oakland Ave
Shorewood, Wisconsin

East Garden Chinese Restaurant

3600 N Oakland Ave
Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Papa John's Pizza

3305 N Oakland Ave
Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Hubbard Park Beer Garden

3565 N Morris Blvd
Shorewood, Wisconsin