Calderone Club

We made online reservations for a party of 4 at 5:15 pm for Saturday, July 9th outside seating due to me being a cancer/transplant patient. That is safer for me due to the risk of getting Covid. We made these reservations a day before and got confirmation via email. We got to the place on time and they said they didn't have our names on the list and everything was booked. I explained that I got confirmation and showed them the confirmation email and they didn't honor or tried to accommodate us. This is the very first time we tried this place but very disappointed at the experience. It seemed like if you weren't "regular customers", there wasn't available seating on the patio. We were seated inside, the food was good but the seating arrangement was not a good experience.

The best Italian restaurant on the north shore by a mile, and possibly the best Italian place in the MKE region. Great neighborhood feel to the restaurant, classic crooner music playing, great friendly service, warm atmosphere. The food is delicious. Try the eggplant parmigiana. Pizza is thin crust, very tasty. Owners personally greet you when you walk in. Highly recommend.

Really good service. The food was wonderful. The sauce on the pasta was very light and tasty. The garlic bread was perfect not too garlicky and light. The desserts were awesome. I think tomorrow we are going to tey the pizza. If you are ever in the area I would definitely look this place up. We will be back for sure.