Yonkers Pizza Company

I had to cancel my trip to NYC this week due to family health issues. ???? To sooth the craving of a good NYC-style pizza I had a veggie slice at Yonkers Pizza Co. this evening, plus their Jimmy’s sausage roll. Outstanding!!! Perfect crust, flavorful and plenty of filling. Friendly staff, cozy place. Just wish they hadn’t discontinued their spinach & cheese roll....

Pizza is great and fairly priced! They don’t advertise it, but you can get any specialty pizza by the slice for 3.75. The amount of topping they put on their pizza is ridiculous! One slice is honestly probably enough to fill you up depending on how many toppings you get.

Alright.. First off, I'm born and raised in the Bronx, NY and have grown up eating the best pizza NY has to offer. I had high hopes for Yonkers Pizza but it just did not deliver. My 12 year old grabbed her pepperoni slice and after finishing it said, "The slices are so big, but it taste so bad." Unfortunately I hate to say it, this does not live up to NY style pizza standards. Perhaps because we're in Dallas and it's hard to find good pizza, this place gets better ratings than it should. The pizza was not crispy at all.. even after we retoasted it TWICE. Look at the photos I've posted to see the floppiest pizza you'll ever eat. The toasted raviolis were okay but the sauce that came on the side tasted like raw herbs. Drove 35 minutes based on reviews and I'm telling you, would've been better off ordering Dominos.