About
The owners of Vargo's Pizzeria in Lancaster, New York believe their pizza restaurant offers a unique combination of delicious Italian and American cuisine that separates them from the competition. With their large selection of pizzas, hearty calzones, and eclectic sandwiches, Vargo's Pizzeria strives to serve their customers quality, yet affordable, food in a comfortable and friendly atmosphere.
Restaurant Features
Facilities & Amenities
Restroom- Wifi Available
Kid Friendly
Kid Menu
Kid High Chair
Veg Friendly
Wheelchair Access
Accepted Payments
- Credit Card
- Apple Pay
- Google Pay
Ratings for Vargo's Pizzeria
Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!
- Overall Rating
google
doordash
facebook
grubhub
yelp
Reviews for Vargo's Pizzeria
We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.
We ordered a pizza there the other night and despite a payment screw-up (on our end), they got the food to us and the owner was incredibly helpful and kind in resolving it. And the pizza and wings were fantastic, honestly some of the best I’ve ever had. Just moved to the area, Vargo’s will definitely be our go-to.
Called at 10:11pm was told it was going to be delivered within an HR. A large pizza extra cheese sausage pepperoni and bacon, one dozen mild wings at the tune of 68$ its is now 11:42 no delivery yet and tipped driver 5 bucks for delivery on my card worked 16 hrs today just wanted some dinner .... Got my food at 11:53.... It was great... wings crispy, pizza cheesy, crust perfect.... I dont mind paying premium prices for good food...just worked 16 hrs was told within hour for delivery, price very expensive, its a mixed reviews because I got a call back and was asked how u food was.... Now know this. There is no free food or reimbursement involved in this review, order at your own risk I will never do delivery again or probably come back to this place again
Don’t leave to many reviews about bad experiences but I’ll write this one. Called to order door dash last night around 1045/11pm AFTER a long day/night working almost 12 hours. Ordered stuff shells and a pizza. Shells, not bad a little dry but decent flavor, sauce was solid thumbs up. Pizza a little expensive for the size and extra toppings we ordered. $2 a shot (Black olives, banana peppers, onions and pepperonis). Dough a little over done, cheese was not melted very well and room temperature. But it wasn’t horrible. The reason I’m giving it two stars today is HORRIBLE service. Even though we ordered from door dash, I called about an hour after I placed the order just to check and see how it was coming. “Vargos pizza we closed at 12” (Click). I was hung up on. Called back again, “Vargos pizza we closed at 12” with a not nice attitude (Click) a second time I was hung up on. Called back a third time a woman answered the phone and as I started to explain the situation was interrupted and
Photos

Business Hours
| Sunday: | 2:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Monday: | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Tuesday: | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Wednesday: | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Thursday: | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Friday: | 12:00 PM - 12:00 AM |
| Saturday: | 4:00 PM - 12:00 AM |
