About
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery in Reynoldsburg, Ohio is a family owned business that serves both pizza and bakery items. It is an Italian restaurant with homemade pizzas, hoagies, salads, and calzones. The bakery offers a wide selection of homemade desserts such as cakes, pies, muffins, and pastries. Tyler's has been a family-owned and operated business since 1986 and prides itself on serving delicious, fresh food to their customers.
Ratings for Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery
Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!
- Overall Rating
google 
yelp 
facebook 
tripadvisor 
foursquare 
zomato
Reviews for Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery
We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.
So sad to have to leave such a low review. Tyler’s has always been a 5 star pizza experience as far as I’m concerned, but my most recent food experience just a few days ago, the first since 2020, was poor at best. Everything that made Tyler’s so yummy has changed—no more airy crust or lots of cheese. No flavor. $40 for two pizzas that definitely weren’t any better than Little Cesar’s . I ordered 2 pizzas with double toppings (which means I paid extra…) and they were bare and dry. The crust was thin and overly chewy as if it wasn’t made correctly, barely any sauce, hardly any toppings. Sigh. I love to support small independent businesses, but I won’t be trying Tyler’s again.
Excellent pizza! Cooked perfectly with flavorful sauce/spices. Top 5 in Columbus area! Definitely worth the 30 min. drive!
We ordered a pizza that was awesome as always. Wasn't planning on getting pastries but they were giving samples of cinnamon rolls,so I surprised my son and husband with them. Never disappointed thank you.
Photos
Business Hours
| Sunday: | Closed |
| Monday: | Closed |
| Tuesday: | Closed |
| Wednesday: | 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Thursday: | 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Friday: | 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Saturday: | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |