Thunder Bay Grille Pewaukee

Ordered the Beef Wellington with Parmesan Garlic Potatoes and the salas bar. Omg the salad bar was amazing. It had 2 soups plus all the fixings to have a salad to die for. We also ordered 4 cheese stuffed mushrooms. They where also amazing. When it came to the Beef Wellington I was not impressed. The puff pastry was raw I was looking for a nice golden brown crust. As you see in the photos it was not a flaky crust. The hubby also had Beef Wellington with fries and asparagus. He also agreed that the crust was not cooked property. We would go back to try other items on the menu. Very cool place to look at all the native american items and motif.

I had only been here years ago for their brunch which was always delicious but this past week we went for dinner and the food, service, and, atmosphere was top notch. Will be back to try more menu items. Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes … More

We stayed next door at the Holiday Inn a couple times and we have eaten here 2 times. I personally like the layout and the location as there are not too many bigger restaurants like Thunder Bay in the area. Now the food is honestly sometimes confusing. They have some dishes that are very good and others that are just bad it's weird how things vary so much. Being in the business consistency is key and I see that being one problem and another is their recipes are little off. For example their bruschetta had melted goat cheese on it and it killed the whole flavor of the dish. The salads were good and the chicken and shrimp were great. We will keep trying different dishes when we're in the area. It's a solid place that would be even better with some subtle changes.