The Village Squire (McHenry)

Worst service. Our saganaki was a big chunk of cheese under cook. The drinks were more awful. This place is just dirty and unkempt. I will never go there again. What a waste.. Food : 1/5 | Service : 1/5 | Atmosphere : 1/5 Recommended dishes Chicken Fingers, Saganaki … More

I have been Herr many times but a visit last night was very disappointing. Service was very slow and seemed to be all servers were very young. When food came the salad was small, I ordered prime rib which was expensive but also I'd say 75% fat & the rest was so rare I could barly eat. I had ordered it medium well. Pictured below will show, I have as presented and then after I removed all the unedible fat. Very disappointing. Potatoes & veggies were cold when received with the plate and not as good as I remember. I think maybe it's going downhill. Kid-friendliness: Had some coloring options for kids Parking: Plenty of parking

Worth recommending. Food and service is typically pretty good; prices are a bit higher, but on par for the portion size you receive. My only recommendation is to eliminate pasta from your menu. The chicken parmesan, pasta, and tomato sauce were inedible. Stick to your specialties - they are what make you shine!