About
Pizzeria New York in Reynoldsburg, Ohio is a popular take-away pizzeria, offering meal delivery throughout the local area. Customers can select from a variety of mouthwatering Italian dishes, such as pizzas, pastas, and salads, with options for those with no time to cook themselves. The pizzeria's fast and friendly service has earned the loyal following of many local residents, making Pizzeria New York the go-to destination for delicious Italian fare.
Ratings for Pizzeria New York
Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!
- Overall Rating
google
facebook
Reviews for Pizzeria New York
We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.
BEST PIZZA IN OHIO ! Man I found out About this place while giving birth to my twins , I’m from New Jersey so it’s just a different kind of pizza I like ! The one cut into 8 slices ???? The food was great prices was more than affordable! My new weekly pizza place ‘ COME GRAB YOU A PIE OF PIZZA ???? THE CHEESE CAKE WAS AMAZING ILL BE BACK ! Vegetarian options: Not only meat products
Thank you all! The People : They have been so friendly and accommodating. These people take pride in their job , are enthusiastic, very invested and enjoy what they do and share their knowledge!!! They offered to re- heat my pie saying “You can’t have cold pie!” Nick even contacted me in well-advanced notice, apologized even though there was no fault ; (I placed order earlier in the day, where brick oven needed more sufficient time warm; he asked if I wanted to cancel or change times. Those Pies: It’s another gem using the family’s original recipe brought from Queens. These are well balanced and tasty pies in all dimensions of crust , sauce and cheese to which I’ve tried the plain or cheese pie!!! Even their side salad was terrific!!! Their menu was larger than I expected , and have heard the appetizers, and wings are also great! It’s highly recommended to GET A PIE OR MORE.
Really good pizza! We ordered pepperoni on all but two slices (for the kiddos) which they seemed to accommodate but then cut it wrong so the cheese slices ended up being half pepperoni half cheese anyway. But not a huge deal, I just re cut those slices when I got home. The pizza itself was really good. My husband and I both really liked the crust and taste. Huge slices and very Floppy - reminded me of Mikey's Late Night Slice. Good price. We also ordered Garlic Knots which were really good as well! ????
Photos

Business Hours
| Sunday: | 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Monday: | Closed |
| Tuesday: | 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Wednesday: | 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Thursday: | 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM |
| Friday: | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Saturday: | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
