PIZZA 1905 Lake Mary

Tried Pizza 1905 due to the great reviews. We ordered an 18” Uncle Tony NY cheese pizza with no toppings. UNFORTUNATELY! this was one of the worst pizza’s we have tried in Florida. It was like it was under a heat lamp all day, which you can see in the picture. The cheese was hard, and when taking a bite, it turned out the cheese was not even attached to the pizza! The dough under the cheese was gluey. On top of that, it had zero flavor. Whole pizza went in the garbage! May as well have picked up a $5.00 Hot & Ready pizza from Little Caesars! Sorry to the owner this is FAR from New York Pizza, don’t bother replying!

If you’re looking for a deep dish pizza this is the place to go!!! Holy cow I as it incredible. And the service was very friendly both over the phone and while waiting. Thank you! We will be back

I’m not one to write reviews, tonight I am taking the time to do so. I have to say I was quite nervous to give pizza 1905 a try do to the fact that I’ve never heard of them before here in Seminole County and I also read a few reviews that weren’t so good about them. But they proved those reviews wrong maybe those days weren’t their days but that Chicago Deep Dish Pizza was the best I’ve ever had. Very filling, had enough with one slice definitely had some leftovers the next day best believe. Thank god we found them. No more driving to Orlando for deep dish. Looking forward to trying the other pizzas and desserts they serve. Thanks !