NYPD Pizza Lake Cay

Garlic Butter Chicken Wings: The chicken wings were perfectly cooked. They were tender and juicy without any red on the bone. The garlic butter was scrumptious with a decent amount of garlic. The blue cheese was ok-ish. It tasted generic and kinda bland. Carnegie Hall Chicken Club Pie: It was delicious. The topping went really well together with the ranch dressing. There’s enough toppings so that you can get mostly everything with each bite. Manhattan Meat Lover’s Pie: The only not so great item we had. The crust were soggy near the middle of the pie. There’s simply too much topping, which made it very salty. You can’t really taste anything other than saltiness. Atmosphere & Services: We ate at around 5:30pm on Monday, so the place wasn’t packed. It was very chilled, and everyone seemed to enjoy their meals. The server was friendly and attentive.

Convenient location near the convention center, easy to get in and out with ample parking due to being in a shopping center. I had dine-in lunch on a weekday; the place was very busy but the staff was friendly and the service was still quick. I ordered a 10" pizza ("Queens Deluxe Pie") and the quality and quantity of toppings was perfect. Nice thin pepperoni, flavorful sausage, and the onions were not overpowering. Surprisingly not very greasy either. The crust has a great chewy texture while still maintaining a slightly crispy outside. My daughter had the lunch special which included a bowl of fettuccine Alfredo (half the dinner size) and a side salad. The side house salad had a fresh quarter tomato, thinly sliced red onion, croutons, and thick cucumber slices. The prices are great, especially if you order a pre-set specialty pizza versus adding a custom list of your own toppings. The New York theme is unique and unobtrusive. I did not visit the bar area but it looked cozy

Any chance I can I try NY style pizza ????????????. I was excited to find this place. The pizza maker was very skilled when tossing that 18" dough up in the air. I tried a half pepperoni and half cheese ????. I found the pizza a little to chewy for my taste and it wouldn't hold up if you tried to hold it by the crust and bite the tipped end. The flavor wasn't bursting like I expected. I give four stars because I love NY style pizza and I want every pizzeria to be successful long enough to get it right.