About
New York Pizza Garden in Fishers, Indiana is a pizza restaurant that seats up to 40 people. They serve classic Italian and New York style pizzas prepared with homemade recipes. In addition, they offer a variety of fresh salads, stromboli, calzones, and toasted subs. The restaurant also offers a full-service bar and an outdoor patio.
Ratings for New York Pizza Garden
Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!
- Overall Rating
google 
yelp 
tripadvisor 
facebook
Reviews for New York Pizza Garden
We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.
Pizza was burnt. I honestly was disappointed.
Update: tried the 3-piece perch with fries, pretty good. Just tried the 6 piece chicken wing special, crisp and crunchy-delicious. Pizza was well made very tasteful.
Our family of 6 purchased over $40 of pizza here for carryout dinner. It was not good. No one in our family thought this was good pizza. We all thought that a mediocre quality frozen pizza from the grocery store would have been better and saved us money. We chose this place because Little Caesar's was not taking online orders due to being too busy, and New York Pizza Garden had over 200 reviews with 4.4 stars. After the fact, we noticed many reviews were old, and after reading more- realized there were not many good reviews. Other review sites had a poor overall review. I hope this place will heed the reviews and improve the quality of their product. We all want to see "Mom and Pop" type places succeed, but they have to put out a quality product that also deserves the price charged.
Photos
Business Hours
| Sunday: | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Monday: | 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Tuesday: | 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Wednesday: | 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Thursday: | 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Friday: | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |
| Saturday: | 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM |