About
My Tomato Pie in Amherst, New York is a unique combination of Italian, American, and banquet hall cuisine. This restaurant offers a wide array of options, including pizza, sandwiches, and salads, as well as a more formal dining area for those looking for a special occasion experience. Whether you're looking for a traditional Italian dish or a more American-style dinner, My Tomato Pie in Amherst, New York has something on their menu to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters.
Ratings for My Tomato Pie
Boosted accuracy with combined honest ratings!
- Overall Rating
google 
doordash 
facebook 
yelp 
tripadvisor
Reviews for My Tomato Pie
We only show the 3 most relevant reviews to save you time.
Excellent food. Menu has a lot to offer. Parking lot has plenty of room to park. Have always gotten a seat without any wait time. Food comes out quite quickly. Staff incredibly nice and attentive. Inside main dining room lighting is a little dim. Have also been there for a baby shower and the staff were wonderful. They work with the WNY Alzheimer's Chapter and have donated proceeds from sales to their campaign annually.
I am so thankful for Tyler from My Tomato Pie. I was looking for a banquet room to gather with family after the Funeral of my 28 yrs old Son-in-law. I called Tyler with 2 days notice and he was kind enough to accommodate us. The food was delicious and the servers were all attentive and kind as well.
There was a bit of a wait tonight, but it was well worth it. Three Tomato Basil soups and a French Onion soup to start. Delicious! If you order anything, order the Tomato soup. The family always look forward to it. The rest of the meal was great as well. Our server was very friendly and quick with the service.
Photos
Business Hours
| Sunday: | 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM |
| Monday: | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Tuesday: | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Wednesday: | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Thursday: | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Friday: | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Saturday: | 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM |