Mamma Mineo's Pizza

I almost gave 3 stars but added a 4th simply because I had a phenomenal experience our first time. So we ordered the Mamma’s special sub and Spicy pizza a couple weeks ago. I’m not kidding when I say every day since then I’ve wanted to order from them. The pizza was phenomenal, and the sub was indescribable. Perfect amount of ingredients, tasty sauce and the bun was other world like. Lightly toasted, and buttery delicious. It was like the outside was lightly coated with a butter garlic sauce. It was so fantastic. So we placed a large 3 family order tonight and we’ve been hyping up this sub to everyone we know. We get home and open the subs and was sorely disappointed. The crust wasn’t buttered like last time and it was actually quite burnt. Ingredients were still really good but the sauce wasn’t spicy like before. It turned the 5 star sub into a rather dismal 3 stars. I hope to convince the better half to give this place another try but I can tell you if we get subs like today

The pizza dough and cheese were decent but the sauce was too sweet (some people like it like that). I ordered their offer of 2 pizzas with 2 toppings each. The lady refused to put all for ingredients on one of the 2 pizzas, and leave the second one without topping, saying: we can’t do that. I felt that made no sense. I am not sure what difference it makes to them. Anyhow it was a pleasant experience besides that minor inflexibility.

Yum. Worth the 15 minute drive outside of a city with a lot of great food. Friendly service, and even pleases my picky pizza aficionado of a spouse. Will be making this a regular in our rotation.