Costa Pizza Restaurant

Very Disappointed with them. I order with them all the time but After this experience not going back. I ordered 6pc buffalo wings and small Cheese pizza. I got home. Lived in wallingford. Wings have no sauce at all Bascially plain deep fried. I Called the store. The owner said come back and exchange but Unfortunately i lived in wallingford not driving another 25mins for 6pc wings. So he gave me credit. I went back again today and order 6pc wings again. Then he asked me for $5 dollar said already discount... When u give some credit it means free not discount! Then got home open the wings the sauce is only like 3 drops and half bowl of oil. Just look at the picture i posted. Not going back. Go to EST EST EST pizza. Theyre so much better.

Loved it! Costa Pizza really lives up to the Great-Pizza-Reputation of New Haven. Many delicious options of pizzas! I had a gluten free option for my first visit. Yummy! Super recommend this place.

Well after reading these reviews I must say I’m disappointed... was my pizza off tonight?? Are these reviews hyped up for no reason? Or is this pizza place really as good as they say, and tonight they’re just off their game? Anyways, I ordered a large pepperoni, nice and simple. The pizza was very uneven, one side of the pizza was super thick, and holding wayyyy too much sauce, then the other side was crispy and thin. My next tiff was the amount of oregano that was used on the pizza. It was very overwhelming and that’s all we tasted. I might give this place another try if we’re desperate, but sooo many better choices in New Haven if you like good pizza.