Caradaro Club Pizza

Very, very Customer service oriented. The pizza is thin crust, just the way we like it. All fresh ingredients. They went out of their way to accommodate us late, just at closing. Vegetarian options: It's pizza, what can I say! Kid-friendliness: It's pizza, what can I say! Parking: Parking can be a challenge, on street parking only. Wheelchair accessibility: Yes

Man alive, talk about a happy accident. We came up looking for a dinner for my wife’s birthday, and literally stumbled upon this joint. We were sat, and the manager Gary came over and started talking with us. He treated us like long lost friends. Such a nice guy, and a great face of the restaurant. The pizza was great, I’m a big fan of the WI tavern style cracker crust. Also- the cheese sticks were a unique and perfect combo of a fried mozz and an egg roll. Sounds crazy, but super delicious. We will 100% be back sometime soon. Thanks for the hospitality!

The first and most iconic thin crust pie in the city. Although other pizza joints may get more attention, it is hard to beat the Caradaro Club experience. Gary is an absolute treasure. Extremely helpful and a blast to talk with; a true wisconsinite to the bone. It took a few times for us to get in, but once we did it was worth the wait. Best pie in the city. Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, garlic bread, etc. Classic pizza joint menu. Kid-friendliness: Kid-friendly approved. Parking: Street Parking, usually you should be find a spot near there no problem.