Cafe Italia - Italian Restaurant

Food looks great ...for those visiting this on Google maps...per their website "new address is 751 Tarpon Bay Road unit 2 Sanibel Fl 33957 (Right behind the Art gallery). Grand opening sometime in September 2022"

Great Food, Service, and Value!! We ordered NYE catering for 9 people to pick up as were staying on Ft Myers Beach. The food was AMAZING and high quality! Everyone was super happy with the dinner and the service was great. We would recommend the Caprese Crostini’s (to die for), Eggplant Parmesan (less breaded than traditional, but we enjoyed more this way), Chicken Marsala, and Tiramisu Cake.

MAKE a reservation! I wish my group was able to eat here. We walked over from a nearby hotel with a group of 5 and we’re unable to be seated an hour from close. We were disappointed as my friend who checked them out online saw the amazing reviews, I can’t say anything about the food but it all looking amazing and I wish we would have been able to dine in. The only reason I’m writing a review is because I wish there was something to say they get quite full as we would have called earlier. I was also slightly disappointed with how the waitress treated us to let us know we were unable to be seated, although I understand they were VERY busy.