Bella Mia's pizza and italian restaurant

I moved here in January 2022 and think I've tried all the local family owned pizza places now. I'm very picky when it comes to pizza and think this is the best in North Fort Myers/Cape Coral area! I picked up two 18" pizzas yesterday and was very, very pleased. The standard crust is about perfect, thick enough so it's not floppy but plenty thin enough to fold it proper for New York style. The flavor of the crust is excellent as are all the ingredients. A very generous portion of cheese and well balanced with the sauce. Now that I finally found this place I highly recommend Bella Mia's and will return again and again and again! :)

Excellent Brooklyn style pizza & amazing crust! Can't wait to try their main dishes next!

Just ordered take out pizza and knots for the first time. The pics on Google make the pizza look soft and fluffy (my preference) but it's definitely thin NY style. Also saw a baby roach (not palmetto bug) run across the counter. Will update my review after I try the food. After food review: Pizza was crunchy (not my style), sauce was the best part, garlic knots were tasty but 2 were pretty burnt. This place has potential but there's other pizza places I'd order at over this one.