Amici's Ristorante & Pizzeria

My local place and I love it. Food is always high quality and well prepared. Plenty of staff makes things move quickly. My favorites here? Pepperoni Pizza and the Sausage & Peppers over Ziti.

I hate to leave bad reviews, especially after seeing so many good ones, but man the service was absolutely terrible. Our waitress was so rude, at one point when we finally waved her down because she just wouldn’t come to our table she stopped, looked at us from across the restaurant & said “what” I was in awe, I asked her if she could please come to our table as we didn’t want to yell out our requests across the restaurant. We legit just left after that (we only ordered an appetizer & sent it back because it was gross). It was the fried calamari, it was not good at all. Maybe their other stuff is good but with the way the waitress treated us, we don’t think it’s worth even going back.

[This is based on their pizza only] Very disappointed after hearing from locals that this was the place for pizza. First time I ordered there and their workers tore the pizza from underneath with the peeler {see attached pics}. How do you send that out when you can obviously see it’s ripped? I was offered a credit for a future pizza. Kudos to the business for honoring me another pizza (I also ordered an additional plain pie); the pizza crust was burned on the 2nd visit (unlike what you see in the pics on Google) and in turn, dried the crust out to saltine cracker level dryness. Sauce & cheese is just ok. I got got for about $30 in total…but I won’t get got again. I’m from Jersey so I kind of know what good pizza should taste like - this ain’t where it’s at.